Friday , 2 June 2017
Home » Housing Finance » Three Ways to Lose a Loan: Major Mistakes Borrowers Make

Three Ways to Lose a Loan: Major Mistakes Borrowers Make

It’s a heady feeling to receive a formal letter advising you that you’ve been pre-qualified for more money than you’ve ever seen in your life.  However, many buyers forget the “pre” part of pre-approval.  Much can happen between pre-qualification and settlement to make that letter worth less than the paper on which it’s written.

Here are three of the most frequent mistakes home buyers make that can cost them their financing and the house of their dreams.

  1. Confusing pre-qualification amounts with loan commitments.

In the bad old days during the housing boom. “no doc” loans (loans approved with little or no income documentation) came in second only to “pulse loans” (if you had a pulse, you got a loan) as leading causes of defaults and foreclosures. Today income documentation is taken extremely seriously by lenders.

However, many buyers don’t understand the differences between pre-qualifications and pre-approvals when it comes to income documentation.  Lenders will check your credit but will rely on estimates from borrowers for pre-qual letters and they don’t require documentation.  A pre-qualified amount is not a sure thing; it’s just the amount for which you might expect to be approved.

For a pre-approval, lenders will ask for recent pay stubs and sometimes W-2s for the most recent one or two years.  They may call employers directly to verify income and employment status.  From self-employed workers or unemployed applicants, they will require signed tax returns, access to bank accounts and brokerage statements, divorce decrees if alimony is involved, to confirm assets.

However, even a pre-approval is conditional.  Credit, debt and income can change during the months that transpire between when a pre-approval is granted, and a buyer actually applies for a mortgage. Lenders won’t issue a loan commitment until it has approved both you and the house in question. This means the home should be appraised at or above the sales price.  A lot can change during that period, and lenders will ask for updated income documentation.

If the documentation differs significantly from the original estimates in a pre-qual due to unemployment, or if income declined in the time between a pre-approval and the lender’s loan commitment, a borrower may find he can’t afford to buy the home he wants.

  1. 2.      Overpaying and triggering a low appraisal

If you ever wondered why anyone in their right mind would pay more for a home than its worth, you’ve probably lived through a bidding war in a hot market.  Emotions sometimes win out over reason and borrowers commit for more than a home is worth.  In fairness, the only way to find out what a house is worth is to have an appraisal done, which is not possible when you are house hunting. Instead, buyers rely on notoriously inaccurate AVMs on popular websites.

Overpaying for a home, especially in a hot market, is an invitation for a low appraisal.  Comps used by appraisers to value a home for a mortgage may have a hard time keeping up with rising prices in a hot market.  They are almost certain to come in lower than an above-market offer in a multi-bid situation.

If the buyer can’t make up the difference on a low appraisal with cash and the seller won’t budge on price, the buyer and their agent can kiss the house of their dreams good-bye.  In July, appraisal issues were responsible for killing 17 percent of all terminated contracts.[1]

  1. 3.      Pulling out the plastic before closing.

Today most buyers, especially first-timers, work hard for many months to save for a down payment and build their credit scores.  Once they’ve received a loan commitment from a lender, it’s easy to assume the worst is over.  Moving and decorating are expensive, and the new home will require a makeover before moving in.  As the days until closing count down, pressure grows to break out the plastic.

Bad idea.  A mortgage isn’t final until the settlement papers are signed.  More than one lender has been known to run a last minute credit check the night before closing, only to discover that their customer’s debt to income score has soared and their credit rating has fallen.



  1. Good information for home buyers to be careful to not do anything that could put their loan approval for buying a house in jeopardy. Any major purchases should be most definitely be delayed by the home buyer until after they get the keys to their new home. Some home buyers buy homes that max out their debt to income ratio for an approval. Adding even a small additional monthly debt in these cases could cause their approval to be withdrawn.

  2. Great article. “A mortgage isn’t final until the settlement papers are signed.” A small point, but signing the settlement papers/loan documents is only the beginning of the end of the mortgage process. Until that new loan actually funds and records, the lender can still “pull the plug” if its final due diligence (which usually involves updating the credit report) reveals a change in the borrower’s financial condition that the lender relied upon when granting the original approval. Waiting to get the keys is certainly a good rule of thumb to cover that interval. Personal confirmation of recording by the new homeowner would take it one step further.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>


Earn a 25% Commission Rebate on Any Home Purchase!